Showing posts with label emotion. Show all posts
Showing posts with label emotion. Show all posts

Monday, March 30, 2009

Feeding back on reflective writing


We had accounts from nearly everyone on the course last week, which was wonderful. It's quite a time consuming task, in selection, reflection and writing. The idea was that this would be a follow on task to the identification of shifts through four levels of writing that we did in Week 2. Through writing our own tasks we would learn what it means to make the shifts and how difficult this might be.

I know from when I wrote my own accounts, when I was on the course, that it's very difficult to stand back and see whether one account is more reflective than another and to know whether you can write reflectively or not. I remember on that course that I was disappointed that I did not get more feedback. But now I understand why and I have seen that some participants on this course have been reluctant to provide feedback on each other's accounts. How do you provide feedback on something so personal? From being a tutor on this course, I know that it's no easier as a tutor than it is as a course participant.

Jenny Moon has pointed out in one of the forums today, that the accounts seem to work better if they are based on something that is very significant and personal for the author - a critical incident - but this requires quite a lot of self exposure.

So as tutors, how are we to assess our students' working, when they will be writing about highly personal critical incidents to which there may be a lot of attached and possibly highly charged emotion. Perhaps we'll be able to get to grips with this week.

Saturday, March 21, 2009

Barriers to reflection

There has not been as much wider discussion this week. Most people have had enough to do contributing to the group work. But there has been some interesting discussion in the Journals forum.

On reading this through this morning, it seems to me that much of this discussion has focussed on 'barriers' to reflection. So it has been suggested that people may not be able to reflect if the topic for reflection makes them feel too uncomfortable or will release emotions that are too strong to handle. Or they may not put time into reflection because it appears too self-indulgent.

There is also the issue of assessment and whether this makes students into 'strategic learners', i.e. they jump through the required hoops to pass the course and if reflection is one of those hoops, they will do as much as is required. But is this really what we mean by reflection and what we want from our students?

And then there is the whole question of 'audience'. Is this an enabler or disabler? It has also been suggested in the Journals forum that establishing communities of reflective practitioners who share their reflections might assist the reflective process, but how much would people be willing to share?

It has occurred to me, whilst writing this post, that thinking about enablers and disablers for the reflective process could be useful - but will these enablers and disablers be any different to those for the learning process as a whole?

Source of image: http://www.accelerated-personal-development.com/image-files/barriers-to-personal-growth.jpg

Friday, March 13, 2009

Big R and little r


The definitions forum has been really interesting. Lots of very thoughtful posts. The discussion about whether there are two types of reflection - big R for formal academic activity which is taught and assessed ( e.g. keeping learning logs etc.) and small r for something more integral to learning and practice has been thought provoking.

Jenny Moon suggests that there are as many types of reflection as you care to define - but whilst we may agree this, it's important for me to be clear about my own definition. For the last couple of years I have had the following definition:

'My own understanding (I hesitate to use the word ‘definition’) of reflection/reflective learning is that it is the process of thinking about my own thinking, actions or learning, with a view to gaining a deeper understanding of them and improving them, so that I can see the evidence in changed behaviour. This thinking will also involve examining my emotional response and how my feelings have influenced my thinking, actions and learning. To make this reflection significant, I need to mark it in some way, by talking about it or better still recording it in written form. Finally, I need to revisit the marked events at some later stage and note whether my learning has improved/moved on.'

I added the bit in bold, last year, when a course participant challenged me to consider how the role of emotion could be included in my definition.

What concerns me, a little, is that my definition has not changed in the last couple of years, which suggests that I haven't made any progress in my thinking. Interestingly I can note slight changes of emphasis and points of interest in both Peter and Jenny Moon's posts on this course, which is an indication of how their thinking has moved over the past year. But I'm not sure that my thinking has changed that much.

The big R, little r notion interested me because I know that I'm quite good on the big R. I do quite a bit of course evaluation and write reports and am able to identify strengths and weaknesses and make suggestions for change. This requires a lot of thinking behind the scenes (reflection on the courses), but I see this as big R. Whilst I learn from this, it is external to me.

Little r, I see as being internal to me and much harder to deal with. This is reflecting on my own learning, behaviour and practice and trying to change this. Whilst I can understand this and I think my definition reflects this understanding, I don't find it so easy to change 'me'.

Jenny Moon has written today:

'Editing is a kind of secondary reflection. I consider that the raw reflection that is first written in jouranls and reflective pieces is of relatively little value. The value is created when the person re-reads and reflects again on the initial reflections.'

I have read this in her books and she has said it on both the previous courses and it makes absolute sense to me. I have also tried to make a habit of revisiting and editing initial writing. However, there still seems to be a big shift to make from that secondary editing process to changed behaviour.

I sometimes feel that I am making exactly the same mistakes that I was making in my childhood :-)

Friday, April 18, 2008

Emotion and Learning


Emotion and learning has only been touched on so far in the course. I think there is a recognition that this is a very important part of reflective learning and also that as tutors we might need to help students deal with their relationship between emotion and learning, but we haven't gone much further than this in our discussion.

Norman challenged me to include some reference to emotion in my definition of reflective learning and I found it very thought-provoking and difficult to include a reference in my definition that would be meaningful. I am still thinking about it.

Jenny Moon has devoted an entire chapter to emotion and learning in her book and discusses how 'learning about emotion and working with one's actual emotions can tend to become confused'. It seems to me that reflecting on learning can also become very confused by emotions. I have just seen an example of this from a participant on another course I attended recently.

A colleague and I are researching the learner experiences of e-learning on a course on which we were also participants. We are exploring the relationship between learning, community, domain, practice and technology and have just started interviewing course participants.

One of the interviewees felt she had a very negative experience on the course. What is surprising (and it shouldn't really be) is the strength and depth of her emotional response to the course. From our point of view as interviewers it has certainly affected how we feel able to approach her. From my perspective, her emotional response appears to have been so strong that she is unable to consider her learning in any form of detached way, so all her comments and responses are influence by her emotions.

I suspect it will be some time before she can detach herself from her emotions and look at the experience in a more detached way.

Now the question is - does reflective learning help you to deal with your emotional response to learning or not?

(030309) I don't think it necessarily helps you to deal with it - more it helps you to recognise it. This recognition may or may not result in changed behaviour in the future.

Source of Image: http://www.wheelerconnolly.com/photogallery/photo20592/Explosion%20of%20emotion.jpg